Fireworks

CD Reviews

Silent Fall - 'Otherwise' http://rocktopia.co.uk/media/reviews/photos/thumbnail/200x200s/4a/ab/3b/812_silentfallotherwise_1289693829.jpg Hot

Added by Central Electronic Brain     November 14, 2010    
 
0.0
 
0.0 (0)
3306   0   1   0   0   0

Artist

Title

There is very little here that hasn't been done many times before.

I am at a loss to know why WMP on my computer suggests this French melodic power metal band (originally called ‘Winterland’) is actually called ‘Fall Silent’! Anyway, have you ever been seduced by the first 45 seconds of an album, only to be ultimately unfulfilled and left frustrated by a largely generic and rather distracting performance? If your answer is “yes” then I think you can empathise with me. ‘Otherwise’ is Silent Fall’s debut album and despite having some really delightful moments of melodic metal bliss (such as those terrific opening 45 seconds!), the sum of the whole has indeed left me feeling at the very least disappointed. Not for one moment do I wish to dismiss the competence and abilities of the band members, and they have clearly absorbed lots of influences that could well provide for future success if they can begin to carve out more of a distinctive niche. But there is the rub.

The album is crying out for the talented players to show us something original. There is very little here that hasn’t been done many times before – although the guys do have a certain panache and absolutely trowel on the layers of melody. So far, so (relatively) good. But then vocalist Adrien Eyraud opens his mouth…Regular readers will know that I have a far greater tolerance of vocalists than several of my Fireworks colleagues. But even I have found this guy to have one of the most heavily accented voices when singing in English that I have ever encountered, and to the extent that it has really bugged me. At times he also seems to be out of tune and/or flat! But this is only part of the problem I have with the vocals, because leads guitarist Olivier Caron introduces some moments of extreme vocals/death metal roars: at the beginning of ‘I Wish’ and during both ‘Play With Fire’ and ‘World Of Secrets’. These are so unnecessary here and add nothing whatsoever to the tracks in question and will surely alienate potential purchasers…and when they intrude towards the end of the otherwise magnificent and less generic ‘On Top Of The World’ – well I just shake my head in disbelief every time!

Fireworks - The Ultimate Magazine For Melodic Rock Music

This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you visit. Cookies used for the essential operation of the site have already been set. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to delete them, see our Privacy Statement.

I accept cookies from this site


‘Otherwise’ is not a complete catastrophe, but it is my view that there should be a complete rethink of the vocal side of things next time around (if there is one), while the songs and arrangements need to focus on material that starts to raise Silent Fall above the morass.

Paul Jerome Smith

Share this on the web.

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

 


Comments (0)add comment

Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy

Member Login



Calendar

<<  June 2019  >>
 Mo  Tu  We  Th  Fr  Sa  Su 
       1  2
  3  4  5  6  7  8  9
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Search Here

Shout Here

Latest Message: 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
  • HenningHallq : Hey guys! I purchased FIREWORKS #87 yesterday and paid by my paypal, but there is still no download link on my account. Can you help me with this? Thanks a lot!
  • Siodmak : Really thanks !!!!
  • Berny : @Siodmak: Pls. do not worry about the error message, we currently have to process orders manually because of a n issue with our payment system. I do not want to bore you with technical details, but the redirection from PayPal to our shop does not work as it should, that's why your purchase is not assigned automatically. We are working on it! Sorry for the troubles & thanks for your understanding. We hope you like the new issue of Fireworks! :)
  • Siodmak : Hello guys : - ) same problem as with previous number: just purchased Fireworks Mag. 87, and this is the message: "We are sorry, but it looks like your transaction failed". I've paid it with paypol. Thanks for your help!!
  • Berny : @Raphone @colorvine: You should have received your download instructions by now, if you haven't, pls. send a mail to «email» - Sorry for the troubles!
  • colorvine : Hello! Purchased FIREWORKS #87 yeasterday and paid by my paypal, but there is still no download link on my account.Can you help? Thanks
  • Raphone : Hello! Purchased FIREWORKS #87 yeasterday and paid by my paypal, but there is still no download link on my account.Can you help? Thanks
  • Berny : Fireworks Magazine #87 is out now!
  • SeaDog57 : Thanks again Berny
  • Berny : Hi SeaDog57: Apologies!Password can be found in the forum, link was (again) added to the "Fireworks" menu.
  • SeaDog57 : Berny; need a download link for #86 and the pg number for the Code
  • Berny : @Siodmark: Pls. check your mail! Apologies for the troubles, we hope you enjoy the magazine! :)
  • Siodmak : Hello guys! Purchased FIREWORKS #86 and paid by my paypal, but there is no download link on my account. Can you please help me? tnks ; - )
  • Hombre 444 : Got mine reading it now,best Rock Mag out on Market by far.
  • Berny : Fireworks #86 is out now!
  • Johns Band : Happy New year Everyone. Will the music film return.
  • Rocktopia Te : The Rocktopia Team would like to wish you a Merry Christmas! :)
  • Rocktopia Te : Fireworks #85 is out now!
  • Berny : @Bill24: Please follow the instructions at «link» or contact me directly at «email»
  • Bill24 : I cannot unzip the mp3's asking for a password. Same one I use to login with? Please someone help. Thanks.
  • SeaDog57 : thanks Berny
  • Berny : The FREE PDF version of Fireworks #82 is still available, including 88 (!!) bonus MP3 songs Just click on the banner on top of the site. Already 800+ downloads and counting!
  • Berny : @SeaDog57: Apologies! Link was fixed, CD 84 is now available from the FIREWORKS menu on top of the page (for registered members only). Thanks & best wishes, B :)
  • SeaDog57 : Doesn't seem to be a download for bonus cd 84 just 2 identical versions of Bonus CD 83?
  • Rocktopia Te : Interviews with Lordi, Dee Snider, W.A.S.P., Myles Kennedy and many more. Check out the Fireworks & Rocktopia interview sections!
  • Berny : We are proud to premiere the new lyric video by MASS! Check out the news section.
  • Berny : Hi biggywiggymusic: Sorted out, apologies for the delay.
  • biggywiggymu : Hi I just ordered download of 84 - took my PayPal and then it said I didn't pay. Have the transaction number. Can someone help?
  • Rocktopia Te : Fireworks #84 is out now!!
  • amcc1888 : Thanks Berny

Only registered users are allowed to post

Follow Us

FacebookTwitterYoutubeGoogle

This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you visit. Cookies used for the essential operation of the site have already been set. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about the cookies we use and how to delete them, see our Privacy Statement.

I accept cookies from this site